Baking
Substitute for Star Anise
No star anise? Use about ½ tsp anise seed per whole star, 1 tsp fennel seed for a milder note, or ½ tsp Chinese five-spice in braises and stir-fries.
- vegetarian
- vegan
- gluten free
Quick answer
Out of star anise? The most versatile swaps:
- 1
Anise seed
About ½ tsp seed for 1 whole star
- 2
Fennel seed
About 1 tsp seed for 1 whole star
- 3
Chinese five-spice powder
About ½ tsp for 1 whole star
Star anise gives a dish a strong licorice aroma with a deeper, woody and slightly bitter base. Its licorice note comes from anethole, the same compound in anise seed and fennel seed, which is why those seeds are the natural substitutes. What they lack is star anise’s warmth and depth, which matters most in long-simmered broths and braises.
Broths and braises
Pho, red-braised pork, master stock and Chinese soy-braised dishes usually steep one or two whole pods in liquid for an hour or more. Anise seed gives the closest flavor; tie it in cheesecloth or a tea infuser so it can be removed. Fennel seed is milder and more herbal, so use more. For red-braised or soy-braised meats, Chinese five-spice powder adds star anise plus its usual partners, which suit those dishes.
A small piece of cinnamon stick or a single clove with the anise seed brings back some of the woody depth that seeds lack.
Baking and sweets
Biscotti, poached fruit, mulled wine and spice cakes use star anise for its sweet licorice aroma. Anise seed works well; it is traditional in many European cookies. Crush the seeds lightly for batters, or grind them finely so they don’t stay crunchy. For poached pears and mulled drinks, add whole seeds in a bundle.
Stir-fries, rubs and marinades
Five-spice is the easiest choice for char siu, roast duck and stir-fry sauces. In dry rubs, ground star anise or ground fennel spread more evenly than whole spices.
When not to substitute
Pho and Chinese master stock owe their character to star anise’s woody depth; anise seed or fennel make a lighter, sweeter broth. If the broth is the point of the dish, it is worth waiting for whole pods. For herbal teas, avoid any star anise of uncertain origin because of the FDA warning about Japanese star anise contamination.
Common mistakes
- Using five-spice in desserts. The Sichuan pepper and clove make sweet dishes taste savory.
- Adding too much ground star anise. It becomes bitter and medicinal quickly.
- Leaving fennel or anise seeds loose in a clear broth. They scatter through the soup and are hard to remove.
- Buying decorative star anise for cooking. It may be the toxic Japanese species.
All 4 substitutes at a glance
| Substitute | Ratio | Best for | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anise seed CookingBaking | About ½ tsp seed for 1 whole star | pho broth, poached pears, biscotti, mulled wine | Anise seed and star anise get their licorice flavor from the same compound, anethole, so this is the closest match. Anise seed is sweeter and lacks star anise's woody, slightly bitter depth. A starting point, since star pods vary in size; tie seeds in cheesecloth for broths. |
| Fennel seed CookingBaking | About 1 tsp seed for 1 whole star | braised pork, tomato sauces, sausage, roast vegetables | Also rich in anethole but milder and greener, so more is needed. Toast lightly and crack the seeds to release flavor. It reads as Italian rather than Chinese in delicate dishes. |
| Chinese five-spice powder Cooking | About ½ tsp for 1 whole star | red-braised pork, char siu, roast duck, stir-fry sauces | Usually contains star anise along with cinnamon, clove, fennel and Sichuan pepper. Those other spices are strong, so this is a savory swap only, and the dish gains clove and cinnamon notes. |
| Ground star anise for whole CookingBaking | About ½ tsp ground for 1 whole star | cakes, cookies, spice rubs, marinades | An approximate conversion; ground star anise is potent and turns bitter in excess. In clear broths, the powder clouds the liquid; in batters and rubs, it disperses better than a whole pod. |
Substitute calculator
How much star anise does your recipe call for?
- Anise seed½ tsp anise seed
- Fennel seed1 tsp fennel seed
- Chinese five-spice powder½ tsp Chinese five-spice powder
- Ground star anise for whole½ tsp ground star anise
Amounts are rounded to practical kitchen measures. Swaps without a fixed ratio, or that can't be measured in the unit you picked, show their ratio instead.
Topics: star anisespicelicoriceasianbaking All baking guides
Frequently asked questions
Is star anise the same as anise seed?
No. Star anise is the woody, star-shaped fruit of a Chinese evergreen tree, Illicium verum. Anise seed comes from Pimpinella anisum, a herb in the carrot family. They taste similar because both are rich in anethole, but they are unrelated plants.
Is star anise safe to use?
Chinese star anise sold as a spice is recognized as safe in food by the FDA. A related tree, Japanese star anise (Illicium anisatum), is toxic and looks nearly identical when dried. In 2003 the FDA warned against star anise teas after illnesses linked to them. Buy from food suppliers, not decorative or craft stock.
Can I use anise extract instead of star anise?
In sweet baking and drinks, yes, a few drops at a time. It is concentrated anethole flavor without the woody depth, so it works in cookies, syrups and custards but tastes artificial in savory broths.
How do I remove star anise from a dish?
Count the pods when they go in and fish out the same number before serving. Broken points can snap off, so place the pods in a tea infuser or cheesecloth bundle in long braises.
Sources
- FDA warning on star anise teas, NutraIngredients
More baking substitutes
Substitute for Cardamom
No cardamom? For 1 tsp ground, use ½ tsp cinnamon plus ¼ tsp nutmeg in baking, cinnamon and ginger in chai, or ½ tsp allspice in rice and meat.
Read
Substitute for Cinnamon
Out of cinnamon? Use apple pie or pumpkin pie spice one-for-one in baking, half as much allspice in savory food, or swap cassia and Ceylon with a small adjustment.
Read
Substitute for Nutmeg
No nutmeg? Mace is the same fruit and swaps one-for-one. Otherwise use half as much allspice, or apple pie spice at the same amount in sweet baking.
Read
Substitute for All-Purpose Flour
No all-purpose flour? Bread flour swaps cup for cup, use 1 cup + 2 tbsp cake flour per cup for tender cakes, and half whole wheat for muffins and breads.
Read