Substitute for Canned Tomatoes

Perfect canned tomato alternatives for sauces, soups, and stews. Fresh and jarred options that work beautifully.

Substitute for Canned Tomatoes
Cooking vegetarian vegan gluten-free

Quick Answer

The best substitutes for canned tomatoes are: Fresh Tomatoes (Blanched & Peeled), Tomato Sauce + Water, Tomato Puree + Water. Each works differently depending on your recipe needs.

Canned tomatoes are a pantry staple for sauces, soups, and stews. When you’re out or prefer fresh alternatives, these substitutes maintain that essential tomato base.

Canned vs. Fresh Tomatoes

Canned tomatoes are picked at peak ripeness and processed immediately, often providing better flavor than off-season fresh tomatoes. They’re also pre-peeled and have consistent texture.

Substitution Success Tips

Fresh tomatoes may have more water content, so cook longer to concentrate flavors. Taste and adjust seasoning, as canned tomatoes often have added salt.

Looking for more ingredient alternatives? Check out these related guides:

Educational Disclaimer: This information is for cooking purposes only.

All Substitutes at a Glance

Substitute Ratio Best For Notes
Fresh Tomatoes (Blanched & Peeled) 1.5 lbs fresh = 1 can (14 oz) tomatoes peak tomato season, fresh flavor, homemade sauces Blanch 1 minute, ice bath, peel, then crush. May need longer cooking time.
Tomato Sauce + Water 1 cup sauce + 1/4 cup water = 1 can tomatoes smooth sauces, soups, when texture isn't important Already seasoned, so adjust recipe spices accordingly.
Tomato Puree + Water 3/4 cup puree + 1/4 cup water = 1 can tomatoes thick sauces, pizza sauce, concentrated flavor Thicker than canned tomatoes. Add more water if needed.
Tomato Paste + Water 3 tbsp paste + 1 cup water = 1 can tomatoes emergency substitute, when only paste available Less complex flavor. Add pinch of sugar and salt to improve taste.
Sun-Dried Tomatoes + Hot Water 1/2 cup sun-dried + 1 cup hot water = 1 can tomatoes intense flavor, Mediterranean dishes, concentrated taste Soak 20 minutes, then chop. Much more intense flavor than canned.
Jarred Tomatoes 1:1 replacement all canned tomato uses, premium flavor Often higher quality than canned. May be more expensive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to remove seeds from fresh tomatoes?

Not necessary for most recipes, but removing seeds prevents bitterness in delicate sauces.

Which substitute works best for pasta sauce?

Fresh tomatoes during peak season or high-quality jarred tomatoes provide the best flavor.

Can I use cherry tomatoes instead?

Yes! 2 cups cherry tomatoes = about 1 can. They're often sweeter and need less cooking time.

Related Topics

canned-tomatoes fresh-tomatoes sauces cooking pantry

Related Guides